skip to main content skip to footer

Lunch & Dinner Menus

Lunch

Light Fare

Crab Cake

15.99

Our award-winning, signature crab cake. Simply the best!

Steamed Shrimp

Peel and eat domestic premium shrimp seasoned with Old Bay®

1/2 lb. 13.99 | 1 lb. 23.99

Fried Oyster

13.99

A locals favorite! Plump select oysters, shucked and fried to a golden brown. Served with Sriracha po’ boy sauce

Hand Prepared Calamari

11.99

Marinated in buttermilk, breaded and served with house aioli

Hot Wings

Seasoned and tossed in your choice of hot, mild, jerk, garlic parm, Old Bay® or Asian sauce

(6) 7.99 | (12) 13.99

Oysters Rockefeller

11.99

Local seaside oysters with a traditional Rockefeller topping and a hint of Pernod

Oysters Parramore

3.99

Local seaside oysters topped with lump crabmeat and our signature sauce baked to a golden brown

Each

Clam Fritters

6.99

Three of Ms. Shirley’s pan-fried homemade clam fitters

Onion Rings

4.99

Go ahead! Treat yo’self!

Garlic Clams

12.99

A dozen local steamed middle neck clams flavored with garlic butter and fresh herbs

Seaside Oysters

Half Shell* or Steamed

1/2 Dozen 8.99 | Dozen 15.99

Flounder Fingers

9.99

House Autry or tempura fried. Served with Sriracha po’ boy sauce

Fried Pickles

7.99

A favorite of locals & pregnant women alike! Served with Sriracha po’ boy sauce

Hot Crab Dip

11.99

Creamy crab meat blend seasoned with Old Bay®. Served with toasted bread

Chicken Tenders

9.99

4 large all-white meat tenders fried to perfection. Served with honey mustard sauce

Crab Hushpuppies

7.49

An Island House twist on this timeless classic

Quesadillas

Served with sour cream and salsa

Cheese 6.99 | Chicken 11.99 | Shrimp 12.99 | Crab 14.99

Soup & Salads

Dressings:
Wasabi Cucumber, Honey Mustard, Pepper Parmesan, Ranch, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Raspberry Vinaigrette and Blue Cheese

Salad Entreé Options:
Add a succulent entrée to any salad.
Grilled or Blackened Chicken (Healthy Option) 4.99
Today’s Fresh Catch* - (Healthy Option) market price
Grilled or Chilled Steamed Shrimp (Healthy Option) 7.99
Fried Oysters 10.99

Buffalo Chicken Chopped Salad

13.99

Romaine, celery, red onion and buffalo chicken tenders chopped and topped with cheddar jack, blue cheese and ranch dressing

Substitute a grilled chicken breast for 1.00 more!

Crisp Wedge Salad

8.99

A crisp lettuce wedge topped with chunky blue cheese dressing, chopped bacon, red onions, tomatoes and blue cheese crumbles

Caesar Salad

7.99

Torn romaine crowns dressed with shredded parmesan cheese and topped with our house croutons. Served with Caesar dressing

Island “House” Salad

8.49

A medley of fresh romaine and spring mix tossed with seasonal vegetables and topped with blended cheeses - a meal all by itself!

Cedar Island Salad

17.99

Our award-winning, signature crab cake over fresh mixed greens with blended cheeses

Side Salad

3.99

Fresh greens and crisp vegetables with your choice of dressing

Soup of the Day

Ask about today's offerings in a small or large bowl

Sweet Treats

Daily specials – Ask for other sweet tooth options, including our cheesecake!

Famous Chocolate Bread Pudding

With Coffee Patron® creme anglaise

Becca’s Smith Island Cake

Crème Brûlée

Yes, it’s awesome!

Sandwiches

Served with your choice of french fries, cole slaw or apple sauce. Enjoy sweet potato wedges for .99 or onion rings for 1.49

Fried Oyster

14.99

Succulent fried oysters topped with lettuce and tomato on a fresh kaiser roll

Crab Cake

17.99

Our award-winning, signature crab cake, fried or broiled, topped with lettuce and tomato on a fresh kaiser roll

Chicken Salad

6.99

Our homemade, chunky, all-white meat chicken salad piled high and topped with lettuce and tomato, on a fresh kaiser roll

Cheesesteak

8.99

6 oz. of hand-carved beef piled high on an authentic Amoroso™ roll with provolone cheese

Chicken Wachapreague

15.99

An 8 oz. grilled chicken breast marinated in teriyaki and topped with melted provolone cheese, applewood smoked bacon and fresh lump crab meat

Flounder

13.99

Fried flounder fillet topped with lettuce and tomato on a fresh kaiser roll

Burgers

Served with your choice of french fries, cole slaw or apple sauce. Enjoy sweet potato wedges for .99 or onion rings for 1.49

Island House Cheeseburger*

11.99

Mouthwatering burger topped with lettuce, tomato, and your choice of cheddar, provolone or American

Beyond Burger

11.99

A healthier, more environmentally plant-based alternative to beef!

Burton's Bay Backfin Burger*

15.99

A burger grilled to perfection and topped with applewood smoked bacon, fresh backfin crabmeat, melted cheddar cheese, lettuce, and tomato

Tacos

Served with your choice of french fries, cole slaw or apple sauce. Enjoy sweet potato wedges for .99 or onion rings for 1.49

Fish Tacos*

11.99

2 fish tacos served blackened or fried on flour tortillas and topped with fresh shredded cabbage, diced tomatoes, shredded cheddar jack cheese and siracha po’ boy sauce

Grilled Shrimp Tacos

12.99

2 tacos – each served with three domestic premium shrimp and topped with fresh shredded cabbage, diced tomatoes, and shredded cheddar jack cheese

Platters

Served with your choice of french fries, cole slaw or apple sauce. Enjoy sweet potato wedges for .99 or onion rings for 1.49

Fried Shrimp

14.99

Plump and juicy shrimp fried to a delicious golden brown

Fried Oyster

17.99

Plump and golden fried oysters served with cocktail sauce

Eastern Shore

24.99

Award-winning, signature crab cake paired with piping hot, juicy fried oysters

Flounder

Wachapreague is the Flounder Capital of the World, so you’ll love this one! Served broiled or fried

Market Price

Island House Crab Cake

Our award-winning, signature crab cake (broiled or fried) with tartar sauce

Single 16.99 | Double 26.99

Clam Fritter

9.99

Four of Ms. Shirley’s pan-fried and homemade clam fritters. An Eastern Shore favorite!

Tempura Shrimp

15.99

Beautiful, premium, domestic Gulf shrimp dipped in a light tempura batter and fried golden brown served with creamy horseradish sauce

Beverages

Soda & Juice

2.49

Coke, Diet Coke, Cherry Coke, Mr. Pibb, Sprite, Ginger Ale, Pink Lemonade, Apple Juice, Bottled Water

Non-Alcoholic

O’Doul’s

Imports

Corona, Corona Premiere, Guinness, Heineken

Iced Tea & Coffee

Fresh brewed! Sweet & unsweet 2.49

High Test or Decaffeinated 1.99

Craft, Draft & Seltzers

Ask what’s being served today.

Domestic

Angry Orchard, Budweiser, Bud Light, Bud Light Lime, Coors Light, Michelob Ultra, Miller High Life, Miller Lite, Natural Light, Pabst Blue Ribbon, Rolling Rock, Yuengling Lager

We accept VISA, Mastercard, American Express, Discover Card, Local Personal Check or CASH.

*The consumption of raw or undercooked food such as eggs, shellfish & or meats can greatly increase your chance of contracting a foodborne illness.